Home › Guides › Sell As-Is or Fix It Up First? How to Decide

Sell As-Is or Fix It Up First? How to Decide

Repairing first usually brings a higher price but costs money and time up front. Selling as-is is faster and simpler but typically brings a lower price. The right choice depends on how much work the house needs, how fast you need to sell, and what you'd net either way.

Get your cash offer

Takes about 60 seconds. No commitment, completely private.

Get my cash offer →

General information only, not legal advice. For advice about your situation, talk to a licensed New York attorney or a HUD-approved housing counselor.

Questions to ask

  1. What's broken? Cosmetic updates and big systems (roof, boiler, electrical, structure) are very different.
  2. Can you afford the work up front? Many sellers can't.
  3. How soon do you need to sell? Every month costs taxes, insurance and utilities.
  4. Is the house financeable? Some conditions stop buyers from getting a mortgage.

Costs to count either way

Compare options by net, not headline price

Ask each buyer or agent to estimate what you'd actually walk away with after all costs. The highest price isn't always the highest net.

Repair and listSell as-is for cash
Upfront costYou payNone
TimeMonthsDays to weeks
PriceHigherLower
CertaintyDeals can fall throughCash offers have fewer financing risks
HassleContractors, showings, inspectionsMinimal

When as-is makes sense

When to repair first

The house needs light work, the market is strong, and you have time and funds.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to make repairs to sell my house in New York?

No. You can sell as-is, but buyers and lenders will price in the condition.

What closing costs does a seller pay?

Commonly agent commission, transfer taxes, attorney fees and payoffs. Ask a title company for an estimate.

Is a cash offer always lower?

Usually, in exchange for speed and no repairs. Compare the net amount.

Can I get more than one offer?

Yes, and you should compare.

Get your cash offer

Use the button at the top of this page to start. It takes about a minute, there is nothing to sign to get an offer, and you can always compare it with listing or with other buyers.

The Key Buyers · 194 Jericho Tpke, Floral Park, NY 11001 · 516-366-2592. This page is general information, not legal or tax advice, and rules change. Every situation is different. Last updated: October 2026.